PoSWW 17: Blessed are the Cheesemakers

This one is old, which is not in keeping with the spirit of our PoSWWs and WitCHes. And, we’ve already written on it and talked about it. But, as the GOAT PoSWW, it really deserves its own post. It is an exercise from the textbook Heinemann Maths Zone 9 (2011), which does not appear to still exist. (And yes, the accompanying photo appeared alongside the question in the text book.)

10 Replies to “PoSWW 17: Blessed are the Cheesemakers”

1. Red Five says:

Whilst I’m not normally one to dis a brie…

…in this case I camembert it.

Goat cheese though I do enjoy.

1. John Friend says:

It was very bad so gouda riddance to it.

2. SRK says:

For mine, this crosses over into so-bad-it’s-good territory (at least comedy-wise). The sort of thing you could show to a good class so everyone can have a laugh.

3. Red Five says:

Laugh, because the only other response is to cry.

4. Terry Mills says:

What is the purpose of this question? If this is the best problem that the composer can find about the application of quadratic functions, then let’s skip applications all together.

Applied mathematics deals with applying mathematics. One has to know the mathematics before one can apply it. Furthermore, the context of the problem must have some intrinsic interest.

5. Red Five says:

And therein lies the real PoSWW.

There are MANY good applications of quadratics.

This is not one of them.

1. Glen says:

Classic.

6. If that first shop window has between -8 and 6 cheeses on display, that means that the second shop window has a negative number of cheeses on display, whatever that means.

Mmm, negative cheese…

1. marty says:

You have a point, but I think I’d still vote for the cheese. With the rectangle question, one can at least discern what they were thinking. I don’t see how to even try to think up the cheese question. Also, the rectangle nonsense has appeared on other occasions, like here (without the rectangle). Indeed, Maths Zone has the rectangle crap. Just before the cheese, Exercise 8 concerns a postage stamp of area mm …

But, really, we’re talking Federer versus Laver here. They’re both deserved winners.

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.