Sorry guys, it ain’t gonna happen. Burkard’s and my 2022 critique was time-consuming and exhausting and stressful. We’re not doing it again. Ever. So, for this year the Discussion posts (here, here, here, here, here, here and here), and the Errors post will have to do.
Just a quick note, however, about the relevance of the 2022 critique. Along with the five Major errors, Burkard and I had sections devoted to: minor mathematical issues (including further errors); poorly conceived questions; poor writing; poor exam structure; and delay and dishonesty in the exam reporting. All of these issues are as concerning or more so in 2023.
The definition of insane exam production is using the same process over and over again and expecting different results.