WitCH 130: Shoo

Here’s the next one from the 2017 Year 7 test, again the calculator part. It’s not nearly as bad as the first question, but it’s so goddam lazy it really had to be included.

UPDATE (09/03/24)

We’ve just noticed that this stupid shoe question also appears in the Year 7 demo test, with a notable alteration:

The use of “proportion” here is bad, and wrong, but at least they tried.

12 Replies to “WitCH 130: Shoo”

    1. Maybe “Express the fraction of orders which are for purple shoes as a decimal number”? Otherwise, you could argue that “this” could refer as easily to 57 or to 1000 as to 0.057.

    2. Thanks, peter. The purposelessness of such questions is standard.

      At this stage, the entire numeracy thing is simply a meaningless ritual. ACARA and their fellow clowns simply do not care if the scenario makes any plausible sense, if the question is testing any solid mathematics in any coherent manner, as long as Johnny is doing something with some physical or commercial or business thing. It is all completely insane.

  1. Am 100% sure such questions have mushroomed in schools since.
    0.057
    Most students would know anyway.
    Years ago, as a freshman substituting a “competent teacher” I found a question in the test to be administered:
    Find the value of x in 5/x : 15/21
    The topic was – ratios
    So, diplomatically, “did you mean 5 : x = 15 : 21 ?”
    The former was used and most student got the right answer of 7. No issue, freshman.

    1. Or perhaps 5/x = 15/21.

      The ‘competent teacher’ had probably done several examples in class, abusing the notation in each example, so of course most students would ‘understand’ what was meant and how to play the game. I wonder what the textbook questions looked like …?

    1. Thanks Marty – those two links made for interesting reading that should be compulsory for anyone setting or checking a public test or examination!

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

The maximum upload file size: 128 MB. You can upload: image, audio, video, document, spreadsheet, interactive, text, archive, code, other. Links to YouTube, Facebook, Twitter and other services inserted in the comment text will be automatically embedded. Drop file here