It could be that they are required to do this under procurement requirements. The insanity of neo-liberalism/markets can do anything is well and truly still driving the public service.
No, I don’t believe it is formally required. Less formally, tendering is hardly unreasonable. But it is very easy to see how, in this instance, it could very badly wrong.
As I read this, the Authority is still directing the revision of the curriculum and the role of the academic they manage to recruit will be in a subsidiary role. This may be a form of “professor-washing” with the Authority doing what is likes with possibly conflicting advice from these experts. What are the criteria for selecting the winning proposals?
In the 1990s, the Ontario (Conservative) government put out a tender for revising the syllabus for a group who ostensibly would come up with a complete proposal. While several publishers showed interest, a group at the Fields institute formed and ended up submitting the only proposal what was accepted. We came up with something that reflected the interests of the various parties (not an easy thing to do), but found that the provincial government made some changes that compromised some of its coherence.
I hope that in Victoria you can organize a group of teachers at schools, universities and colleges that can have the breadth and coherence to counter the charlatans who undoubtedly will have the ear of some of the politicians and strength to insist that they have some control over the final result.
Thanks, Ed. It is not exactly the professor washing that it may appear to be, but it is not a good move, and is indicative of a broader culture of not goodness.
Tony Gardiner wrote in a comment how it used to be, and in particular in Melbourne. Thomas Cherry and then E. R. Love were the high priests of senior school mathematics, but the priest model disappeared 40+ years ago, and the role(s) was taken over by a network of bureaucrats and education academics and teachers. They have ruled and have fouled the roost ever since.
It is only in the last few years that mathematics academics have become significantly involved again, if not enough. There has been an on-going cold war between the established forces of nonsense and the revolutionary forces of sense; within VCAA, this appears to be a civil war. The new position would appear to be a victory for the revolutionary forces, but the tender is retrograde step: rather than professor washing, it may result in the very strong mathematicians already in place being replaced by weaker but cheaper semi-maths types.
A good job for you Marty! At least you know how to add up! The assessment should reflect what post-secondary education wants students to know!
It could be that they are required to do this under procurement requirements. The insanity of neo-liberalism/markets can do anything is well and truly still driving the public service.
No, I don’t believe it is formally required. Less formally, tendering is hardly unreasonable. But it is very easy to see how, in this instance, it could very badly wrong.
As I read this, the Authority is still directing the revision of the curriculum and the role of the academic they manage to recruit will be in a subsidiary role. This may be a form of “professor-washing” with the Authority doing what is likes with possibly conflicting advice from these experts. What are the criteria for selecting the winning proposals?
In the 1990s, the Ontario (Conservative) government put out a tender for revising the syllabus for a group who ostensibly would come up with a complete proposal. While several publishers showed interest, a group at the Fields institute formed and ended up submitting the only proposal what was accepted. We came up with something that reflected the interests of the various parties (not an easy thing to do), but found that the provincial government made some changes that compromised some of its coherence.
I hope that in Victoria you can organize a group of teachers at schools, universities and colleges that can have the breadth and coherence to counter the charlatans who undoubtedly will have the ear of some of the politicians and strength to insist that they have some control over the final result.
Thanks, Ed. It is not exactly the professor washing that it may appear to be, but it is not a good move, and is indicative of a broader culture of not goodness.
Tony Gardiner wrote in a comment how it used to be, and in particular in Melbourne. Thomas Cherry and then E. R. Love were the high priests of senior school mathematics, but the priest model disappeared 40+ years ago, and the role(s) was taken over by a network of bureaucrats and education academics and teachers. They have ruled and have fouled the roost ever since.
It is only in the last few years that mathematics academics have become significantly involved again, if not enough. There has been an on-going cold war between the established forces of nonsense and the revolutionary forces of sense; within VCAA, this appears to be a civil war. The new position would appear to be a victory for the revolutionary forces, but the tender is retrograde step: rather than professor washing, it may result in the very strong mathematicians already in place being replaced by weaker but cheaper semi-maths types.