Nicky Nicks Off

Last month, it was announced that Nicola Phillips, Provost at the University of Melbourne, was to become Vice Chancellor of Adelaide University. Unimelb’s fond farewell noted,

During her time at the University of Melbourne, Professor Phillips demonstrated her deep dedication to the University, extending across her leadership of academic strategy and innovation, widening participation, and the many dimensions of culture change that she has championed and resolutely pursued in matters of equity, inclusion and conduct.

Nicky was also really good at sacking people.

We considered Phillips early this year, when writing about the unfair dismissal of Aleks Owczarek, a professor of mathematics at Unimelb. Our focus then was more on the Dean of Science, Moira O’Bryan’s, nasty emails to the Mathematics Department. But it was Phillips who waxed lyrical and hypocritically about “power imbalance”, and it was Phillips who wielded the axe, decreeing that Owczarek should be dismissed, a decree subsequently overturned at the Fair Work Commission.*

A Unimelb colleague has recently alerted us to two more FYC cases involving the University of Melbourne and, in particular, Phillips. One case, still in the FYC works, involves the dismissal of a marketing professor, for “nastiness” or “screaming” or something. With the professor’s appeal against dismissal still in play and with no real details to go on, we’ll leave it be; for news reports, see here and here (M,P).

The second case, involving an engineering professor, is in ways similar in factual basis to the Owczarek thing. Also, as with Owczarek, it was Phillips’ decision to dismiss the professor and, as with Owczarek, Phillips’ decision was subsequently overturned by the Fair Work Commission, with the order that the professor be reinstated.

The engineering case seems to us significantly more egregious than Owczarek’s egregious dismissal, but we won’t go into details.** There appear to be two stark conclusions, however, from the FWC judgments on the two cases:

1) The dismissal laws, as instantiated in the the Fair Work Act and the University’s of Melbourne’s Appropriate Workplace Behaviour Policy, provides the University with broad license to be vicious;

2) The University of Melbourne has been significantly more vicious than the broad viciousness to which they were legally entitled.

Anyway, Nicky is now off to Adelaide University. What “dimensions of culture” does Nicky have planned? Will Nicky instigate there the same culture of “equity, inclusion and conduct” that she championed at Melbourne? As it happens, there is no need. It is no great surprise that Adelaide has already proven itself very accomplished at throwing their academics under a bus in the pursuit of absurdity. But, Nicky will fit right in.

Good bye, Nicky, and good luck. To Adelaide.

 

*) True to form, the University of Melbourne has apparently appealed FWC’s Owczarek decision. The University is, of course, blind to the hypocrisy of whining about an “abuse of power” while wielding their massive institutional and financial power in continuing to pursue the matter. 

**) For those who want to get a sense of the engineering case, the following paragraphs of the FWC decision are of particular note: 1, 2, 7, 16, 21, 27-28, 43, 51, 58-60, 66. Our sense after a semi-close reading is that DP Colman’s decision in the engineering case is more confused and less convincing than DP Bell’s in the Owczarek case. DP Colman also seems colder, less concerned and thus less understanding of the almost inevitable clumsiness of adult relationships. Nonetheless, DP Colman did not ignore the fundamental harshness of the University’s conduct, which formed the basis of his ruling.  

Power Games at the University of Melbourne

UPDATE (06/09/26)

The University of Melbourne appealed the FWC decision. The appeal decision was handed down on 04/09/26: the UoM lost their appeal and have been ordered to reinstate Owczarek. There are things to say about this decision but I won’t unless and until it seems appropriate to do so.

UPDATE (08/09/26)

The Australian has a vicious and voyeuristic report on the FWC decision.

**************************************

Last month, just as Christmas was crashing in, Professor Moira O’Bryan, the Dean of Science at the University of Melbourne, found it “necessary” to email all staff at the School of Mathematics and Statistics. Why? Well, it all began a year ago. Or, four years ago, depending upon how you count. But let’s begin a year ago. Continue reading “Power Games at the University of Melbourne” →

Melbourne’s “Toxic” Arts

Having given Monash University a whack, it’s time to take a quick look at the University of Melbourne. A couple of intriguing reports about the University appeared earlier this week in Melbourne’s Age newspaper. The reports are most interesting for what was not written.

The first report, by Kylar Loussikian and which appeared on Monday, detailed allegations apparently raised by Professor Jennifer Milam, Head of the School of Culture and Communications. Professor Milam is reportedly in a legal battle with the University of Melbourne, stemming from accusations of bullying against her.

That battle is notable (and see an earlier report here), but the focus of Loussikian’s report, and his second report with Tom Cowie the following day, was on a more general issue, the supposedly “toxic” environment in Melbourne’s Faculty of Arts. That characterisation appears to be due to the university’s former vice-chancellor, Professor Glyn Davis.

According to Loussikian and Cowie:

  • A legal review conducted by the University of Melbourne “found four heads of school [in the Faculty of Arts] were ‘undermining’ acting dean [of Arts] Denise Varney“.
  • Professor Varney, who had been in the School of Culture and Communications, was promoted to acting dean in February. Academics claimed to The Age that school heads had been discouraged from applying for the acting dean position.
  • Milam has “alleged to have implied that the faculty [of Arts] was hiding profits”.

There’s plenty more detail and colour in Loussikian and Cowie’s reports, including the suggestion that the four heads in question could be investigated for misconduct, which “could lead to dismissal”. Two of the heads are also named: Professor Milam and Professor Trevor Burnard, who was head of the School of Historical and Philosophical Studies up until July and who is reportedly leaving the University.

So, what is really going on? God only knows. But there is one glaring question underlying all this: if those four heads in Arts were indeed “undermining” Dean Varnie then why were they undermining her? What is the underlying substance of the dispute? The secondary but still important question is how Professor Varnie came to be acting dean. If heads in Arts were discouraged from applying, then by whom, and why?

We know nothing about this dispute other than what has been reported. There’s plenty nasty we could say in general about Australian arts and humanities and vice chancellors and heads and deans. We have friends at the University of Melbourne who pretty much loathe everything about the place. But can the systemic awfulness of Australian universities offer any insight into this very specific dispute? God only knows.

All that seems clear is that there’s a larger and, we’ll guess, more important story that, for whatever reason, Loussikian and Cowie aren’t telling.

Monash Extends a Backhander

One of the better offerings for Victoria’s senior students is Extension Studies. Corresponding roughly to America’s Advanced Placement program, ES permits a school student to undertake a university subject as part of VCE, albeit as a lower weighted, fifth or sixth subject.

The extension studies program is not without its flaws. In particular, there are no externally defined curricula or standards, with, rather, each participating university shaping their ES subjects to match their own university subjects. Consequently, there is significant variance in the content, quality and difficulty of the ES subjects offered. This also creates issues for the AP aspect of the program; on occasion, students aligned with one university have had difficulty receiving credit from another; this subject mismatching has also been exacerbated by the arrogance of some university administrators. It can also be a non-trivial task finding keen and competent teachers for ES which, as always, means the wealthier private schools benefit much more than public schools. And, some weirdness from VTAC hasn’t helped matters.

Nonetheless, extension studies functions reasonably well overall and can be of genuine value to a keen or strong student. Apart from the immediate reward of richer study while at school, ES can give a student a jump on their university education and effectively lower their uni fees. (The fees, one is always obliged to mention, which were introduced by this Labor asshole.)

Which is why Monash University’s decision this year to cease offering extension studies is so disappointing, and so annoying. This has created the ridiculous situation where the John Monash Science School, which is, you know, Monash University’s science school, is having to look elsewhere for their extension studies. And of course it is not just future JMSS students that are being screwed around.

What was Monash’s reason? All they wrote to ES subject administrators was, “In recent years, there has been a consistent decline in the number of students taking up this opportunity due to a range of factors.”

Yeah, well, maybe. Maybe numbers have declined, although enrolment in mathematics (with which we’ve been associated) has been healthy and stable. And, Monash might have mentioned that amongst the “factors” in that “range” are Monash’s relatively high cost for a participating student, combined with Monash’s effective discouragement of the participation of smaller schools.

It’s difficult to tell what is really going on, what is the real reason for Monash’s decision. The obvious suspicion is it has to do with money, although the program is not administratively heavy and ought to be pretty cheap to run; indeed, it’s the individual departments that have to pay for the academics to teach and administer and grade the subjects, almost certainly at a loss. The Mathematics Department has always lost money on the deal, and has never whined about it.

The other suspicion is that Monash’s extension program wasn’t attracting sufficient school students to study at Monash, whatever “sufficient” might mean. In contrast, the Mathematics Department has never worried about whether the program attracts more students to do mathematics at Monash; they’ve just accepted that that’s what a principled Department should do.

So, what was it? Was it Monash engaging in particularly obtuse neoliberal bean counting? Or, was it Monash disregarding any notion of community obligation? We’re not sure. But, we’re guessing the answer is “Yes”.