We really want to get on to other things, but this needs to be done. Below is pretty much a complete cataloging of *Nelson*‘s use of the adjective “complex” in the five recent WitCHes (here, here, here, here and here). To be clear, there is tons more wrong, and bad, in the selected excerpts in the WitCHes: the proper WitCH updating, currently scheduled for late 2029, will be long and painful. But the use of “complex” warrants particular attention. It reflects VCAA’s complex madness, and we doubt that it is a coincidence. Continue reading “A Sum of “Complex” Numbers”

# Tag: complex numbers

## WitCH 119: Poly Want a Cracker?

Last one. These are excerpts from the final section of *Nelson*‘s complex numbers chapter. Similar to the previous WitCHes, I’ve tried to not be manipulative material in selecting the material except, of course, in selecting the worst bits: the worked examples not indicated are standard, and in general the working is tedious but ok; a monotonous but essentially correct proof of the conjugate root theorem is included in the text.

## WitCH 118: The Chaos Factor

I was gonna go with *The Sot-Weed Factor*, but that was too cute a title, even for me.

We’re now getting to the VCAA-related material, which prompted this whole series. The last two sections of *Nelson*‘s complex numbers chapter are on factors and roots of polynomials. Below are excerpts on factorisation. (For the sake of interpretation, note that: the factor and remainder theorems are stated reasonably clearly, but of course with no hint of a proof; these two theorems are followed by two standard “worked examples”; the working of all the worked examples is painfully earnest and slow, but is close enough to correct.)

## WitCH 117: The Roots of Disunity

There is still a big issue in the previous WitCH that I believe no one has noted, but let’s continue. Here are excerpts from the next subchapter of *Nelson*‘s chapter on complex numbers. Continue reading “WitCH 117: The Roots of Disunity”

## WitCH 116: Polar Bare

This is our second WitCH on *Nelson*‘s chapter on complex numbers. As with our first WitCH, we have not excluded any definitions or arguments or explanations from the text that would fill apparent (and actual) gaps in the selected material; the rest of the subchapter consists of routine examples and less problematic (but far from unproblematic) exposition. Continue reading “WitCH 116: Polar Bare”

## WitCH 115: Not So Complex

Last year we took a multiwhack at VICmaths, Nelson’s Year 12 Specialist Mathematics textbook, specifically at *Nelson*‘*s* chapter on logic and proof: see here, here, here, here, here and here. This post is the beginning of a second multiwhack, this time at *Nelson*‘*s* chapter on complex numbers. Continue reading “WitCH 115: Not So Complex”

## PoSWW 31: Really?

Honestly, we cannot believe it. We’ve checked it ten times and we still cannot believe. It’s from the 2022 Specialist Mathematics Exam 2 (**08/11/23**. The exam is here.), and nothing beyond the discussion on the exam post needs to be added. But, after last year’s screw up, and anyway, it has to be posted.

## How the Other Maths Lives

A few days ago, the *Sydney Morning Herald* had an article on “the hardest question” from this year’s NSW Extension 2 Exam. The question is worth 5 marks, which equates to 9 minutes of a 3 hour exam (accessible here). The question, and another question (6-ish minutes), which apparently came along for the ride, are posted below. Readers’ homework exercise is to Compare and Contrast. Continue reading “How the Other Maths Lives”

## WitCH 74: Aargh!

## PoSWW 22: A Distant Reality

Please make it stop. This one is a multiple choice question from the 2009 Specialist Exam 2. The examination report gives the answer as A, without comment.