WitCH 149: Tasmania Has Deloitte to Learn

Yes, this is Deloitte, Part 2. Last year, while Victoria was in the midst of the 2024 leak debacle, it seems that Tasmania was going through something akin to Victoria’s 2023 admin-typo debacle. A number of “errors” were found on senior exams, leading to Tasmanian Assessment Standards & Certification instigating an independent review by – who would’ve guessed – Dial-a-Leech, Deloitte. Continue reading “WitCH 149: Tasmania Has Deloitte to Learn” →

Deloitte Dénouement

Long, long ago, when you were little boys and girls, I lodged an FOI. This FOI concerned the Deloitte debacle. My request was broad and complicated but in brief the FOI – in actuality, two related FOIs – requested:

1. All of VCAA’s discussions and analyses, both internal and external by VCAA request, of the five major errors on the 2022 VCE mathematics exams.

2. The Terms of Reference of the review of the mathematics examination development process commissioned by the Victorian Curriculum and Assessment Authority (VCAA) in March 2023, as well as documents prior and subsequent to the commencement of the review, that indicate the formation of and the conduct of that review by VCAA.

That FOI process has now finally run its course. About a month ago, I received VCAA’s re-revised response to my FOIs. As I will explain, there is a key element of the debacle that remains a mystery, and I still had the right of (re)appeal to OVIC. My feeling, however was that VCAA handled my broad and difficult FOIs in exhausting (if sometimes clumsy) good faith, and that nothing was likely to be gained by appealing. Continue reading “Deloitte Dénouement” →

VCAA Has Deloitte to Learn

Last year, as seemingly occurs every year, there were serious errors on the VCE mathematics exams. This was reported on at the time by the Age, on the basis of a teacher’s complaint and a comment on this blog. The errors were reported on again last month by the Herald Sun, on the basis of a parliamentary submission. I was pleased to see these reports although they were not my doing. I did not notify any reporters of the exam errors and no reporter had asked me for comment until after the recent Herald Sun and Guardian articles on this year’s General Mathematics exam errors.

As I routinely do, I quickly blogged on some (but not all) of the 2022 errors (here, here, here and here), but other than that I had been as quiet as possible about the whole thing, even on this blog. For a reason, and until now.

Continue reading “VCAA Has Deloitte to Learn” →