The Thrilling Epsilon Lemma

Yesterday, I posted an inequality proposition for readers to ponder:

Suppose that \color{RawSienna}\boldsymbol{a} and \color{RawSienna}\boldsymbol{b} are real numbers, and suppose that for every \color{RawSienna}\boldsymbol{\epsilon>0}, we have

    \[\color{RawSienna}\boldsymbol{a\leqslant b + \epsilon\,.}\]

Prove that \color{RawSienna}\boldsymbol{a\leqslant b}.

The discussion was very interesting, and thank you very much to the industrious and thoughtful readers-commenters. I had planned an update, but there turned out to be a lot that I thought worth writing, and so I decided on this separate post. Continue reading “The Thrilling Epsilon Lemma” →

TNDOT Friday 15: Trigonometry

Lots to catch up on, and over the week-end I’ll begin updating the posts with solutions people have provided, but let’s keep things rolling.

Below are the final three questions from the 1913 Matric trigonometry Honours exam. This follows on from TNDOT 13 and TNDOT 14, and noting Q7 below has already appeared (and solved), as TNDOT 4. As background, the other trig TNDOT posts are TNDOT 1, TNDOT 2 and TNDOT 8.

Have fun.

Continue reading “TNDOT Friday 15: Trigonometry” →

Terry Mills’ VCAL Problems

When not making annoying non sequitur comments on the blog, Terry Mills works very hard to be a very good teacher. This includes hunting for and working hard to create mathematical resources for his students. One such is a list of problems compiled by Terry. Prompted by Sunday’s problem-solving post, Terry reminded me yesterday of his collection. As Terry put it,

A few years ago I taught a class of VCAL students; VCAL was the predecessor of Foundation Mathematics. I was told that these students are not interested in mathematics; they all want to go into a trade; so teach them something about building.

I met the students and indeed many did want to go into a trade: building, electrician, beauty therapy, or hospitality. Some were there because they had never been successful in mathematics. Some came to Australia as refugees and did not speak English very well.

What did they have in common? Nothing!

So I decided to give classes devoted to solving problems.

Attached is what grew out of my experience.

Many of Terry’s problems are not “problems” in the sense of Sunday’s post (although what constitutes a “problem” is very much in the eye of the beholder). But, whatever one calls them, it seems to me be a very nice collection, very suitable for the students it would suit.*

*) Terry i forgiven for Questions 31 and 32 (just).

How Does One Teach Problem-Solving?

Yes, it is Problem Season here in Crapland. Yesterday there was a new TNDOT, with a couple others still outstanding, and there are more problems, below. But I am less interested in solutions to the problems below than I am in how one might teach them, if that is even the proper phrasing. How, generally, does one teach the techniques, or perhaps the art, of problem-solving? Continue reading “How Does One Teach Problem-Solving?” →

TNDOT Friday 14: Trigonometry

Let’s get back to work, and to fun. The TNDOT got derailed by the VCE exams, and the exams screw-up, so let’s try to get it back on track. TNDOT 12 is still there: not of that much interest but people can contribute, and I’ll try to polish that one off with solutions in the next few days.

The one that is open and interesting, from a few weeks back, is TNDOT 13, comprising the first three questions from the 1913 Matric trigonometry Honours exam: a few people have commented and appear to have come up with solutions, although not much has been posted; people are definitely welcome to and encouraged to post solutions. This one is a continuation of that 1913 exam: the next three questions. As background, the other trig TNDOT posts are TNDOT 1, TNDOT 2, TNDOT 4 and TNDOT 8.

Have fun.

Continue reading “TNDOT Friday 14: Trigonometry” →

TNDOT Friday 13: Trigonometry

(Yes, there will be a Secret General Exam Business post, later today, and good luck to you or your students.)

Ok, no one had too much to say about last week’s TNDOT, which is fine. Although there were a couple of things to note, I think, it wasn’t of that much interest, and was posted mainly to complete that particular exam (Pass Algebra 1911). I’ll update the TNDOT soon.

This one is also part of completing an exam, but it should be more challenging and more interesting. The questions are from the 1913 Matric Trigonometry Exam, of which Q2 (TNDOT 2) and Q7 (TNDOT 4) have already been posted.  (See also the other trig posts: TNDOT 1 and TNDOT 8.)

The exam consisted of nine questions in total, and here are the first three (repeating Q2 from TNDOT 2). Have fun.

Continue reading “TNDOT Friday 13: Trigonometry” →

A Primary School Parable

Once upon a time, there was a mathematician, let’s call him Marty. Marty had two young daughters, who attended a small primary school, a public school strong in community spirit but not swimming in money or mathematical expertise. So, Marty often pondered about offering his mathematical services to the school. For this reason and that pandemic, however, he never got around to it. Then, one day, Marty was contacted by one of his former students, let’s call him David.

David was a teacher at a nearby secondary school. David’s school was swimming in money and mathematical expertise. The students at David’s school were required to take a subject focussed upon community service, and David wondered if his students may be able to somehow help out at Marty’s school. So, David and Marty and another parent, let’s call her Moneypenny, met to chat about it. Then they met with the Principal, let’s call him Peter. Peter was happy to give things a go. Thus, Maths Club was born. Continue reading “A Primary School Parable” →

TNDOT 3: The Remainders of the Day

Here’s a third entry in our Teaching New Dogs Old Trigs Tricks series: the first three questions from the 1907 Victorian Matric Algebra exam.* As well as the computational aspects, readers might be interested in contemplating what was expected for the proof parts, as well as how one might fruitfully present such results to students now, a century later.

*) TNDOT 2 is also in the process of being updated. Stay tuned.

Continue reading “TNDOT 3: The Remainders of the Day” →