The Problem of Conceit and the Importance of Conception

A couple weeks ago, I wrote about my brother Jeff happily declaring women to be objects, and the philosopher Frege’s attempts to untangle concepts from the objects to which those concepts may apply. The point, apart from the self-indulgent pleasure of reminiscing and of pondering such things, was to raise the question of the meaning and the value of categorisation: how do we distinguish this from that and what is the value in doing so? The broader purpose of that post was to provide a (gratuitous and elaborate) introduction to two posts on Ashman and his dismissal of conceptual understanding. And, here we are, with Post Number 1.

Continue reading “The Problem of Conceit and the Importance of Conception” →

The Difference Between the Inquiry People and the Explicit People

The Inquiry People know way too little mathematics and do not care, being firmly convinced that it does not matter. On the other hand, the Explicit People know way too little mathematics and do not care, being firmly convinced that it does not matter. Continue reading “The Difference Between the Inquiry People and the Explicit People” →

The Concept ‘Horse’ is an Object

JEFF

Once, when I was a teenager, I was hanging out with my brother Jeff and some of his university acquaintances. The conversation was meandering, in the solving the world manner that students have always loved. At some point, a girl made the very standard complaint,

“Women are being treated as objects.”

My brother, employing his famous Jeffersonian diplomacy, responded,

“But women are objects.”

And the fun ensued. Continue reading “The Concept ‘Horse’ is an Object” →

Travelling Salesmen, Rainbow and the Value of Idiotic Effort

I had been planning this post for a while, but Burkard prompted the post to be moved up the list and prompted some addition to it.

Earlier this year, the result of a friend’s suggestion, I made a rather long drive for a rather short engagement. It was supposed to be two engagements but one person reneged. Such is life; the word of some people is worth more than others’. Anyway, two engagements or one, it was a lot of work for a busy and tired Marty. Was it worth it? It depends upon how one calculates such things, which is the subject of this post. Continue reading “Travelling Salesmen, Rainbow and the Value of Idiotic Effort” →

Two Questions of the Neo-Explicit-Teaching Gang

Regular readers will be aware that I have been writing on my annoyance with the new and growing cult of “explicit teaching”. Sure, it is a much needed correction to the old and seemingly, hopefully, declining cult of inquiry game-playing. But a cult is still a cult, and the spiritual and authoritative leaders of this new cult seem unwilling take any responsibility for, or even acknowledge the existence of, the perverting of good teaching principles into mandated madness. Continue reading “Two Questions of the Neo-Explicit-Teaching Gang” →

How to Succeed at Rosenshine Without Really Trying

1. Rosenshine’s Success Principle

There has been a discussion of late, here and at Greg Ashman’s place and in Elon’s sewer, of whether Rosenshine’s principles are simply general principles – principles which guys like me consider basically good by being basically common sense – or whether Rosenshine’s principles amount to more, um, explicit instructions, which are thereby more open to specific critique. The answer would appear to be either, or neither, depending upon which of the three will sell better in a given context.1 Continue reading “How to Succeed at Rosenshine Without Really Trying” →

Taking Off the Rosenshine

Last week, I wrote a couple posts on the incoming orthodoxy of “Explicit Teaching” and the perverted form it has taken in some schools, with the mandating of PowerPoint lesson plans and of what are either arguably or undeniably scripted lessons. I suggested that, with his strong ET advocacy and his media omnipresence, Greg Ashman (and Ochre) might wish to consider saying something, anything, about this fresh pedagogical hell. A few days later, Ashman responded, in his co-Caiti podcast. Continue reading “Taking Off the Rosenshine” →