Yes, the effect on mathematics writing is the least of our AI worries. This is a post I’d been pondering for a while, however, and a blinkered ABC report last week on Australian Catholic University and AI has spurred me to write it. Continue reading “AI and the Death of the Mathematics Essay”
Tag: writing
What is a Script?

There is a famous story about the great comic playwright George Kaufman, co-writer of the books for the Marx Brothers’ two Broadway shows and then the screenplays for three of their great films. Kaufman was supposedly chatting with someone backstage during a performance of The Cocoanuts, when he abruptly stopped the conversation. Kaufmann apologised:
“Excuse me, I thought I heard one of my original lines.”
Not everyone is inhibited by a script. Then again, not everyone is granted or simply demands as much license as a Groucho or a Chico, and not everyone is the master of improv to so justify that license.
The True Value of Words
Obviously, I’ve been having fun lately, beating the crap out of VCAA Version 2022 (which may or may not resemble VCAA Version 2025). This post is also on exams and exam writing, at least in part, but not in the same crap-beating manner. It’s more of a puzzle for me. Continue reading “The True Value of Words”
Sluts
(Yes, it’s all been too hard, so I’ve decided to do a Rundle and end it all quickly. The title oughta do it pretty well.)
Last month, I wrote a post riffing off Cooking in a Bedsitter, a very funny and much loved cookbook by Katherine Whitehorn. In preparing the post, I read a bit about Whitehorn who, no surprise, turned out to be a very funny and very feisty lady. Whitehorn was a young woman in 50s London and thrived in the liberation of the times. Not mainly sexual liberation, although that also seemed part of it, but more intellectual and social liberation. Whitehorn revelled in no longer needing to be dainty or so proper. For some great little interview snippets with Whitehorn, go here.
The Undeniable Presence of the Bull

Calvin Trillin is one of my favourite writers. Trillin is very much an American writer, essentially unknown in Australia and even in America you have to be the type to want to read his style of journalism and humour. But we of the type love his writing, and the man himself, regarding him as a national treasure. Trillin writes beautifully, with an E. B. White-ish gentleness and elegance, but can also be incredibly funny, particularly about food and eating. To quote one of a thousand passages, here is Trillin in the foreword to his Tummy Trilogy:
From the point of view of a traveling man with a strong interest in immigrants being able to get a toehold in this country by starting family restaurants, the pre-1965 immigration policy was a matter of simple madness: we were basically shutting out the Chinese while letting in as many Englishmen as wanted to come, even if they were dragging their overcooked vegetables behind them. … I have previously acknowledged, when helicopters were snatching people from the grounds of the American embassy compound during the panic of the final Vietcong push into Saigon, I was sitting in front of the television set shouting, “Get the chefs! Get the chefs!”
(A few years ago, Trillin got walloped for a similarly self-centred, ethnic-focussed ditty, which was antipodally misread by a multitude of humourless assholes. The episode was very minor in the scheme of the current offendedness mania but it was about as idiotic as such episodes get and Trillin was defended by no one of stature.)
That is all by way of introduction and this post is not about Trillin. It is about just one great Trillin line and why it has come to mind. In one section of Travels with Alice, Trillin is in Barbados with his wife, Alice, lamenting the difficulty of getting good food in the Caribbean, dreaming of the Italian West Indies and its fabled island, Santa Prosciutto.
Somehow I always arrive for my first visit on a Caribbean island confident that I am going to find something decent to eat. When we arrived in Barbados, Alice reminded me that even my most frenzied efforts in the Caribbean tend not to be fruitful. …
“Don’t forget the bullfoot soup,” she said, referring to a native dish on St. Thomas whose name, I’m afraid, described it with unfortunate precision.
“Well, I’m sure at least that it was authentic,” I said. “It tasted pretty much the way you’d imagine something called bullfoot soup tasting. And there was, of course, the undeniable presence of the foot …”
Which brings us to the International Congress on Mathematical Education.
ICME-15 is on in Sydney right now, with roughly a million maths ed people having flocked in, all now congratulating each other on their brilliant insights. Unsurprisingly, I’ve paid the Congress little mind, but I’ve caught glimpses out of the corner of my eye and one cannot help but ponder. Surely, with a million people sharing their hard work and deep thoughts, there must be something there, right? But then I remember.
I ponder what four decades of mathematical ignorance might produce, and what we have is much as one would imagine. One needn’t bother listening to what these people say. Look instead, always, at what they have produced. It is bull. It is undeniable.
Stapling the Vicar to Damon Runyon

VCAA’s Greater Literary Offenses
The difficulty of critiquing VCAA mathematics exams is capturing the variety and the frequency and the depth of the flaws, and then summing the overall effect, the fundamentally impoverished approach to mathematics and its testing. Documenting straight out errors is not overly difficult, and even non sequitur questions are manageable: the error or weirdness typically speaks for itself. Capturing the ubiquitous awfulness of the writing, and the intrinsic meaninglessness of many of the questions, however, is harder. Continue reading “VCAA’s Greater Literary Offenses”
The Non-Constant Gardner

Recent events – the bastardisation of Roald Dahl and the burning of history – reminded me of a post I had planned long ago, on Martin Gardner and school libraries. It is often said that Martin Gardner is responsible for creating more mathematicians than anybody else. As the fable goes, a bright-eyed teenager stumbles upon a collection of Gardner’s mathematical writing in the school library, they read away on weird topologies and the Game of Life and so on, they are entranced and another mathematician is born. The fable is not true, but it is true enough. Continue reading “The Non-Constant Gardner”
VCAA’s Lesser Literary Offenses
One of the all-time great literary wallops, by one of the all-time great writers, is Mark Twain’s Fenimore Cooper’s Literary Offenses:
Cooper’s art has some defects. In one place in “Deerslayer,” and in the restricted space of two-thirds of a page, Cooper has scored 114 offenses against literary art out of a possible 115. It breaks the record.
There are nineteen rules governing literary art in the domain of romantic fiction — some say twenty-two. In “Deerslayer”, Cooper violated eighteen of them. Continue reading “VCAA’s Lesser Literary Offenses”
The Indelicate Art of the Mathematics Documentary

Mathsy people try very hard to like mathematics documentaries. They will frequently claim that they like them. But they don’t, really, not often, not much. For non-maths people it is much simpler: they don’t like maths documentaries and, if not so intimidated as to hold their tongues, they are generally happy to say so.
The sad reality is that most mathematics documentaries are bad. They are bad art, and they make for bad education.* This was brought to mind by a new Netflix documentary, A Trip to Infinity, and by a recent invitation. The invitation I’ll get to later. The documentary is bad.
Continue reading “The Indelicate Art of the Mathematics Documentary”
